Why I hate price per square foot
It's a receipt, not a recipe. Here's what actually sets the price of your house.

Jeremy Hundley, REALTOR®, Benchmark Realty, LLC
November 21, 2026
Everybody quotes it. “Houses over there are going for $450 a foot.” Then they multiply by their own square footage and figure they know what their house is worth.
Here's the problem. Price per square foot doesn't set a price. It describes one after the fact. Take a sale price, divide it by the square footage, and you get a number. That number is a byproduct of everything that went into the price: the lot, the street, the garage, the condition, the layout, the basement, the train two blocks over. It's a receipt. It tells you what somebody paid. It doesn't tell you why, and it can't tell you what your house will bring.
An experienced appraiser will tell you the same thing. They don't start with a price per foot and work backward. They find the sales most like your house, then adjust for every difference a buyer would pay more or less for. Size is one of those differences. It's one ingredient, not the whole recipe.
What the number leaves out
Divide a price by square footage and all of this disappears into one number:
- The garage. Garages don't count as living space. A house with a three-car garage and the same house with none divide out the same way.
- The lot. A flat half-acre and a steep quarter-acre that drops off behind the house can have identical square footage. They are not identical houses.
- What's nearby. Train tracks, a busy road, a commercial lot next door. A study of freight-rail lines in Cuyahoga County, Ohio, found houses under 1,250 square feet within 750 feet of an active track sold for 5% to 7% less.
- Storage and the space that doesn't count. Attics, unfinished basements, workshops and sheds have real value and add zero square feet.
- Basements and low ceilings. For Fannie Mae loans since April 1, 2022, appraisers count only finished space above ground. A basement goes on its own line even when it's finished, rooms need ceilings of at least 7 feet, and space under 5 feet doesn't count at all. MLS listings and tax records don't always follow those rules.
- Condition. A 1998 original and a gut-renovated house of the same size are different products.
- Layout. Four bedrooms in 2,400 square feet and two bedrooms in 2,400 square feet sell to different buyers.
Even the square footage itself isn't one number. Fannie Mae says plainly that square footage in MLS systems and assessor records “may not be ANSI-compliant,” meaning it may not be measured the way an appraiser measures it.
The builder test
Ask a builder his price per square foot. Say he tells you $200. Now ask him to build you a two-bedroom house with a 14-car garage at $200 a foot. He's going to laugh, because that garage doesn't count as square footage and it sure isn't free.
The same math works against small houses. Every house needs a kitchen, bathrooms, a roof, a foundation, a heating and cooling system, a driveway and a lot to sit on. Those costs don't shrink much when the house does. Spread them over fewer square feet and the per-foot number goes up.
The National Association of Home Builders checked this against Census data on new homes in 2024. With the lot value taken out, homes under 1,200 square feet had a median of $200 a foot. Homes over 5,000 square feet: $132 a foot.
So a small house will almost always look overpriced next to a big one, and a big one will almost always look like a deal. Neither one is true. It's just division.
Here's the part most people miss. Even when appraisers adjust for size, they don't use the average price per foot, because the average includes everything: the land, the kitchen, the bathrooms, the location. A bigger house on the same street doesn't come with a second kitchen or a second lot.
An appraiser in Sacramento showed it with two nearly identical houses on the same street:
- 1,200 square feet: sold for $205,000. That's about $170 a foot.
- 1,000 square feet: sold for $195,000.
If every foot were worth $170, the smaller house should have sold for $34,000 less. It sold for $10,000 less. The extra 200 feet were worth about $50 a foot, not $170. Everything else that buyers pay for was the same in both houses, and that's what made up most of the $170.
How we got here
Most home search sites put price per square foot right next to the asking price. Even our own MLS, Realtracs, calculates it on every listing. When a number is sitting right there next to the price, people use it. It makes me insane.
My opinion on how we got here: in February 2006, Zillow launched with free value estimates on more than 60 million homes, built from public records. All of a sudden anybody could pull up a sale price and a tax-record square footage on the same screen, and dividing one by the other took two seconds.
It's easy. It's also lazy. A number that takes two seconds to calculate is a two-second opinion of value, and the biggest thing most people will ever sell deserves more than that.
Two houses, one street
This one's mine. In 2026, two houses sold on the same street in a Lebanon neighborhood. Same section of the neighborhood, both built in 2021, two months apart:
The smaller one
$749,000
That's about $260 a foot.
2,885 square feet, 4 bedrooms, 3 baths, a level lot. Sold for $749,000 after 13 days on the market.
The bigger one, my listing
$699,900
That's about $215 a foot.
3,262 square feet, 5 bedrooms, 4 baths, a steep wooded lot with a detention pond. Sold for $699,900 after 121 days.
The bigger house, with an extra bedroom and bath, sold for $49,100 less.
Price it by the square foot off its neighbor ($260 times 3,262 feet) and you'd have listed it around $848,000. That's about $148,000 more than anybody paid.
In my opinion, that lot cost about $50,000. And this wasn't a guess. It sat on the market for four months with plenty of showings. Buyers had every chance to say what it was worth, and they said it.
Source: Realtracs MLS, closed sales, Lebanon, TN, 2026. Square footage as entered in the MLS. Deemed reliable, not guaranteed.
Same neighborhood, same year, wildly different numbers
I pulled every house that sold in two neighborhoods, from November 2025 through October 2026.
Westhaven, Franklin. 246 houses sold. Price per square foot ran from $289 to $824. Throw out the extremes and the middle 80% still ran from $412 to $562. On a 3,000-square-foot house, that's the difference between about $1.24 million and $1.69 million. Same neighborhood. Same year.
And the square footage behind those numbers came from at least five different places: builder plans (85 sales), professional measurements (62), tax records (31), prior appraisals (26) and “other” (21). You're dividing by a number that wasn't measured the same way twice.
Lockeland Springs, East Nashville. 42 houses sold, from $266 to $850 a foot. The smallest quarter of those houses sold for a median of $447 a foot. The largest quarter: $393. That's the small-house math from above, showing up right here.
The cheapest per foot was listed at 3,294 square feet. But 1,404 of those feet were basement, and the number came straight off the tax record. Count only the main floor (1,890 square feet) and it sold for $463 a foot, right in line with the neighborhood. It wasn't a bargain. The math was wrong.
Source: Realtracs MLS, houses only (no condos, townhomes or land), closed sales 11/1/2025 to 10/31/2026. Square footage as entered in the MLS. Deemed reliable, not guaranteed.
The basement rule that surprises everybody
Fannie Mae's definition of a basement is about as broad as it gets. A level counts as below grade “if any portion of it is below-grade,” no matter how nice the finish or how big the windows. Their own example: a walk-out basement with finished rooms doesn't count toward the above-grade room count. One wall partly in the dirt on a sloped lot is enough.
Once it's a basement, it comes out of the square footage. It goes on its own line in the appraisal, and Fannie Mae requires every adjustment to “reflect the market's reaction,” meaning what local buyers have actually paid for the same feature. If the comparable sales nearby don't have finished basements, there's not much to back up a number with.
I've seen appraisals give a finished basement zero value. When it does get credit, in my experience it's often cut by half or more compared with the same space upstairs.
So when a listing rolls a finished basement into its total square footage, the price per foot it produces can't be compared to a house without one. That's what happened with the cheapest-per-foot house in Lockeland Springs: 1,404 of its 3,294 “square feet” were basement.
The finished attic
East Nashville has another trap: the finished attic. A lot of older houses there have upstairs rooms tucked under the roof, with angled ceilings, low knee walls and spots where you can't stand up straight. That space often gets counted as square footage. In my opinion it's just not as usable or as valuable to a buyer as the same footage on the main floor, and it's harder to heat and cool.
Appraisers draw a hard line at the extreme. For a Fannie Mae loan, a room with a sloped ceiling counts only if at least half of it is 7 feet or taller, and any part under 5 feet doesn't count at all. A listing or tax record may count every inch. Divide the price by that bigger number and the house looks cheaper per foot than it really is.
What actually sets the price
Here's how an appraiser gets to a number, and how I do it too:
- Find the closest matches. Recent sales in the same neighborhood, as close as possible in size, age, bedrooms, bathrooms, lot and condition.
- Adjust for every difference. A garage, a better lot, a finished basement, a busier street, a new kitchen. Each one moves the price up or down by what buyers in that area actually pay for it.
- Check it against the market right now. Are houses at your price flying off the shelf or sitting? That's what my monthly price-range maps show.
Price per square foot is fine as a quick gut check across a bunch of truly similar houses. It's a terrible way to price one.
Want to know where your house actually lands? Ask me here.
Questions people ask
Is price per square foot a good way to value a house?
Not by itself. It's the result of a sale, not a way to price one. It leaves out the lot, the garage, the location, condition and how the square footage was measured. Appraisers value a house by comparing it to the most similar recent sales and adjusting for each difference.
Why do smaller houses have a higher price per square foot?
Every house needs a kitchen, bathrooms, a roof, a foundation, mechanical systems and land. Those costs don't shrink much with the house, so they get spread over fewer feet. NAHB found new homes under 1,200 square feet had a median of $200 a foot (lot value excluded), versus $132 for homes over 5,000.
Does a basement count in square footage?
Not in an appraisal for a Fannie Mae loan. Since April 1, 2022, appraisers count only finished, above-ground space with ceilings of at least 7 feet. Fannie Mae treats a level as a basement if any part of it is below ground, even a finished walk-out with big windows, and reports it on its own line. Its value has to be backed up by what local buyers have paid for basements, so it can end up worth much less than the same space upstairs. MLS listings and tax records don't always follow these rules.
Does a garage count in square footage?
No. Garages, porches and patios aren't counted as living area, even though buyers pay for them.
Does a finished attic with sloped ceilings count as square footage?
Only partly, in an appraisal for a Fannie Mae loan. A room with a sloped ceiling counts only if at least half of it is 7 feet or taller, and any part under 5 feet is left out. Listings and tax records may count all of it, which makes the price per foot look lower than it is.
Why is my square footage different on Zillow, the tax record and the MLS?
They often come from different sources measured different ways: builder plans, tax assessor records, a prior appraisal, a professional measurement or the owner. Fannie Mae notes that square footage in MLS systems and assessor records may not match the appraisal standard.
What do appraisers use instead?
The sales comparison approach: the closest recent sales, adjusted for differences in size, lot, garage, basement, condition, location and more, using what the local market actually pays for each.
Sources
- Fannie Mae, ANSI Fact Sheet (March 2022)
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-05, gross living area and basements
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-09, adjustments
- NAR, "Why Do Square Footage Disputes Arise?" (2021)
- NAHB Eye on Housing, "Economies of Scale in Single-Family Home Construction" (Sept. 2024)
- Simons and El Jaouhari, "The Effect of Freight Railroad Track Activity on Residential Property Values," The Appraisal Journal (2004)
- Sacramento Appraisal Blog, "How do appraisers come up with square footage adjustments?" (2014)
- Dennis Chanski, SRA, "The focus on price per SF in the appraisal report," NEREJ (2025)
- Zillow press release, Feb. 8, 2006
- Local numbers: Realtracs MLS, houses only, closed sales. Deemed reliable, not guaranteed.
